The Collaborative International Dictionary of English v.0.48:

judgmental \judgmental\ adj.
   1. depending on judgment; as, a judgmental error.
      [WordNet 1.5]

   2. Inclined to make moral judgements about the behavior of
      people; -- contrasted with an inclination not to judge the
      moral qualities of others. Opposite of nonjudgmental.
      [Narrower terms: faultfinding(prenominal) ]
      [PJC]

WordNet (r) 3.0 (2006):

judgmental
    adj 1: depending on judgment; "a judgmental error"; "I think
           that she is too judgmental to be a good therapist" [ant:
           {nonjudgmental]

Moby Thesaurus II by Grady Ward, 1.0:

34 Moby Thesaurus words for "judgmental":
   abusive, blackening, blameful, censorious, condemnatory,
   contemptuous, critical, damnatory, denunciatory, deprecative,
   deprecatory, depreciative, derisive, disparaging, execrating,
   execrative, execratory, invective, inveighing, judicative,
   judicial, judiciary, judicious, juridic, juristic, objurgatory,
   priggish, reproachful, reprobative, reviling, ridiculing, scoffing,
   vilifying, vituperative